An article in JAMA Network on March 9, 2023 addressed the debate about keeping Daylight Savings Time throughout the year. Most Americans do not like changing their clocks twice a year.
So, should Daylight Savings Time (DST) be kept throughout the entire year? More people say they would prefer that to having Standard Time year round. Recently, the Senate voted to have DST be kept throughout the year. However, the House of Representatives did not vote on the bill.
Against making DST permanent throughout the year are health concerns. Studies have shown that there is an increase in poor sleep, depression, stroke (in women), and auto accidents during the first week or two after the switch from Standard Time to DST. Many sleep experts believe that these health hazards persist to some extent during all of DST.
An article by the Sleep Research Society (SRS) stated, “After a thorough review of the existing literature, the SRS advocates the adoption of permanent Standard Time.” They oppose DST because of health, sleep, and circadian biology.” Circadian biology refers to the internal clock that regulates changes in multiple biological functioning that is synchronized to solar time.
Beth Malow, MD is a professor of neurology at Vanderbilt University who has expertise in sleep. She points out that “morning light is really needed to get going in the morning.” Having DST during the winter months would mean that children would go to school in the dark.
Dr. Malow also points out that the amount of daylight does not change by changing the clock. Our social time (e.g., when we go to school or work) determines how much daylight we experience at different times. Daylight is longer during the warmer times of the year independent of how we set our clocks.
The American Medical Association, the Sleep Research Society, and other medical organizations have endorsed eliminating DST and using Standard Time all year long.
Others argue that the greatest health risks are during the couple of weeks following the switch from Standard Time to DST; that concern would be resolved by eliminating Standard Time and making DST year round.
My conclusion is that making either Standard Time or DST year round is better than changing the clocks twice a year. It is more likely than not that Standard Time would have more health benefits than DST year round. However, the health risks from year round DST may not be as significant as they are during the first two weeks after changing from Standard Time to DST.
Peter M. Hartmann, MD
Family Medicine & Psychiatry